Quick Answer

A flat-rate commission check for a New York City resident can have 45.6% withheld: 22% federal, 7.65% Social Security and Medicare, 11.7% New York State and 4.25% New York City. On $10,000 that is $4,560. The state and city rates run above what most reps owe, so part comes back at filing.

New York City is the one place where commission can have close to half of it withheld before it reaches your account. The federal gap that catches reps elsewhere shows up here too, but the state and city lines work in the opposite direction.

How Is Commission Taxed in New York City?

A New York City resident's commission pays four layers of tax: federal income tax, Social Security and Medicare, New York State income tax and New York City income tax. State rates run from 3.9% to 10.9% in 2026. The city's rates run from 3.078% to 3.876%. The city tax is based on where you live, so it follows you if your employer is in New Jersey or Connecticut.

How Much Do New York State and City Withhold From a Commission Check?

On the flat supplemental method, New York State withholds 11.70% and New York City withholds 4.25%. Both figures come from the state's 2026 withholding publications (NYS-50-T-NYS and NYS-50-T-NYC, both dated 1/26). Add 22% federal and 7.65% FICA and you get 45.6%.

Employers can use the aggregate method instead, which withholds on the commission as if it were part of a regular paycheck. Your pay stub shows which one you have. A few small state payroll lines for disability and paid family leave come out too, though they're minor next to the four above.

What Does a $10,000 Commission Look Like in New York City?

The table is for a single filer in the 24% federal bracket and a single filer in the 32% bracket. The first has New York taxable income in the 5.9% state bracket, which runs from $80,650 to $215,400 in 2026. The second has New York taxable income above $215,400, so it sits in the 6.85% bracket. Both pay the city's top rate of 3.876%.

Withheld at the checkOwed, 24% federal bracketOwed, 32% federal bracket
Federal income tax$2,200$2,400$3,200
Social Security + Medicare (7.65%)$765$765$765
New York State income tax$1,170 (11.7%)$590 (5.9%)$685 (6.85%)
New York City income tax$425 (4.25%)$388 (3.876%)$388 (3.876%)
Total$4,560$4,143$5,038
Result at filing$0$417 refund$478 owed

The table assumes the whole commission is subject to Social Security. If you've already passed the wage base ($184,500 in 2026), subtract $620 from the Social Security and Medicare line on a $10,000 commission.

Your bracket decides which column you're in.

Enter your commission, your total pay for the year and New York City. The calculator shows the check and the bill side by side.

Open the Free Calculator

Why Does New York Withhold More Than I Owe?

Both flat rates are higher than the highest bracket they could ever apply to. The state's 11.70% is above its top rate of 10.9%, and the city's 4.25% is above its top rate of 3.876%. Nobody's real marginal rate reaches either flat number, so the state and city withholding on a flat-rate commission check overshoots for every rep.

In the 24% example the overshoot is $580 for the state and $37 for the city, which more than covers the $200 federal gap and leaves a $417 refund. In the 32% example the federal gap is $1,000 and the state and city overshoot is only $522, so the rep still owes $478 at filing.

How Much of a New York City Commission Should You Set Aside?

Federal tax drives the gap, and the New York over-withholding offsets part of it. The 10% reserve from the commission tax post ($1,000 on $10,000) covers the $478 shortfall in the 32% example with room left over, and in the 24% example you're likely to get money back.

Treat the refund as a buffer rather than a plan. It arrives months after the commission, and equity sales or other income can change the answer. If your employer uses the aggregate method, none of this applies in the same way, so check the pay stub first.

Living in New York State outside the city removes the city line: 22% + 7.65% + 11.7% is 41.35%, or $4,135 on a $10,000 commission.

This is education, not tax advice. Brindle Financial is not a CPA firm, and your own numbers depend on your employer's payroll method, your filing status and your other income. Confirm them with your payroll team or a tax professional.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much is commission taxed in NYC?

A flat-rate commission check for a New York City resident can have 45.6% withheld: 22% federal, 7.65% Social Security and Medicare, 11.7% New York State and 4.25% New York City. That is $4,560 on a $10,000 commission, and part of it comes back at filing because the state and city rates are higher than what most reps owe.

What is the New York State supplemental withholding rate for commission?

11.70% for 2026, according to the state's withholding tax publication NYS-50-T-NYS (1/26). It applies when your employer uses the flat supplemental method.

What is the NYC supplemental withholding rate?

4.25% for 2026, according to NYS-50-T-NYC (1/26). It applies to New York City residents when the employer uses the flat supplemental method.

Why is so much withheld from my NYC commission check?

Four lines come out at once: 22% federal, 7.65% FICA, 11.7% state and 4.25% city. The state and city flat rates sit above the highest brackets, which are 10.9% for the state and 3.876% for the city, so the withholding overshoots what you owe on those two lines.

Do I get a refund from New York for over-withholding?

If your total New York State and city withholding is more than your tax when you file, the difference comes back as a refund. The federal side can go the other direction, so look at the combined result before you plan to spend a refund.

Do I pay New York City tax if I live in Westchester or on Long Island?

No. City income tax applies to people who live in the five boroughs. You still pay New York State tax, so a flat-rate check has 41.35% withheld instead of 45.6%, and the 4.25% city line shouldn't appear on your pay stub.

Chris Brindle
Chris Brindle
Financial Planner -- Valor Investments and Planning

Chris Brindle is a financial planner who works specifically with sales professionals on commission, bonus, and equity income. Before becoming a financial planner, he spent time in tech sales -- so he has dealt with variable income, big commission months, and the question of where it all went. He works with clients through Valor Investments and Planning in Easton, PA.

Book a free 30-minute call →